Each batch is hand-crafted in our Ohio City Kitchen
This building got its start over a hundred years ago as a live theater. We got our start in 1999, and since 2014 ice cream has been the show here.
Come by & see what we’re making.
Our Kitchen is always on view, come by and see us baking crumble for Wildberry Crumble, or mixing in the chocolate chunks for Double Chocolate Chunk.
Ingredients we get from
nearby farmer-friends
STRAWBERRIES, BLUEBERRIES, RHUBARB.
Organic. Greenfield Farms.
Fredericksburg, Ohio
PEACHES.
Quarry Hill Orchards.
Berlin Heights, Ohio
APPLE CIDER.
Quarry Hill Orchards.
Berlin Heights, Ohio
FRESH PEPPERMINT, LAVENDER, OTHER HERBS.
Organic. Mulberry Creek Herb Farm.
Huron, Ohio
HONEY.
Greenfield Farms.
Fredericksburg, Ohio
EGGS.
Organic. Free-range -Greenfield Farms
Fredericksburg, Ohio
WHEAT FLOUR, OATS.
Organic. Stutzman Farms
Millersburg, Ohio
MAPLE SYRUP.
McDonald Family Farm
Munson Township, Ohio
ROASTED PECANS, ALMONDS, & PEANUTS.
Hillson Nut Co. Cleveland
MILK & CREAM.
Numerous Ohio family farms.
Ingredients we get from producers far-away
VANILLA.
Fair-trade and organic when available. Madagascar
CHOCOLATE.
Fair-trade. Ivory Coast & Ghana
COCOA.
Organic. Fair-trade. Ivory Coast & Ghana
EVAPORATED CANE SYRUP.
Organic. Fair-trade. Brazil
COFFEE.
Sumatra, Indonesia; South America
MANGOES.
India
RED & BLACK RASPBERRIES, CHERRIES, HAZELNUTS.
Oregon
BANANAS.
Organic. Central America
PISTACHIOS.
California
COCONUT.
Organic. Southeast Asia
PEANUTS.
Southeastern U.S.
CINNAMON.
Organic. Fair-trade. Vietnam
SALT.
France, Brazil, Pakistan
We sincerely thank you for visiting us.
We take pleasure and pride in contributing to our Northeast Ohio communities and to the lives of Mitchells' employees.
-Pete, Mike, & The Mitchell’s Team