OUR ICE CREAM


We handcraft our ice creams one small batch at a time, using local grass-fed dairy and fresh seasonal ingredients.

Allergen, Ingredient, Vegan, and Kosher Information (PDF)

 

  • All
  • Ice Cream
  • Seasonal
  • Sorbet
  • Yogurt
  • Vegan
  • No-Sugar Added
  • VANILLA BEAN

    VANILLA BEAN

    Made with Madagascar Bourbon vanilla beans

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic egg yolks, Vanilla extract and beans, Organic carob bean.

  • CHOCOLATE

    CHOCOLATE

    Made with organic fair-trade French cocoa 

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic fair-trade alkalized cocoa, Organic egg yolks, Organic carob bean.

  • BUTTER PECAN

    BUTTER PECAN

    Butterscotch-pecan ice cream, locally-roasted pecans

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Hillson’s roasted pecans [Pecans, Peanut oil, Butter (Cream, Salt)], Sweetened condensed milk (Milk, Sugar), Organic tapioca syrup, Organic butter (Organic cream, Lactic acid), Natural flavor, Organic carob bean, Baking soda.

  • DARK ROAST COFFEE

    DARK ROAST COFFEE

    Blend of Sumatran and fair-trade South American coffees

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Fair-trade Arabica coffee, Sumatran coffee, Organic egg yolks, Organic carob bean.

  • COFFEE CHOCOLATE CHUNK

    COFFEE CHOCOLATE CHUNK

    Blend of Sumatran and fair-trade South American coffees, fair-trade dark chocolate chunks

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Fair-trade dark chocolate (Sugar, Alkalized chocolate liquor, Cocoa butter, Butterfat, Soy lecithin, Natural flavors), Fair-trade Arabica coffee, Sumatran coffee, Organic egg yolks, Organic soy oil, Organic carob bean.

  • DOUBLE CHOCOLATE CHUNK

    DOUBLE CHOCOLATE CHUNK

    Chocolate ice cream, fair-trade dark chocolate chunks

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream,  Organic fair-trade sugar, Fair-trade dark chocolate (Sugar, Alkalized chocolate liquor, Cocoa butter, Milkfat, Soy lecithin, Natural flavors), Organic fair-trade alkalized cocoa, Organic egg yolks, Organic soy oil, Organic carob bean.

  • BANANA CREAM PIE

    BANANA CREAM PIE

    Fresh banana ice cream, homemade marshmallow ribbon, homemade shortbread crust

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic fresh bananas, Wheat flour, Organic butter (Organic cream, Lactic acid), Organic tapioca syrup and/or corn syrup, Organic eggs, Natural flavor, Kosher gelatin (parve), Sea salt, Ascorbic acid (anti-oxidant vitamin C), Organic carob bean, Cream of tartar. 

  • CARAMEL FUDGE BROWNIE

    CARAMEL FUDGE BROWNIE

    Vanilla Bean ice cream, caramel ribbon, fudge brownie pieces

    INGREDIENTS

    Cream, Skim milk, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic eggs, Organic butter (Organic cream, Lactic acid), Organic fair-trade alkalized cocoa, Stutzman Farms’ organic wheat flour, Sweetened condensed milk (Milk, Sugar), Organic tapioca syrup, Natural vanilla flavor and beans, Sea salt, Organic carob bean, Baking soda.

  • CARAMEL SEA SALT

    CARAMEL SEA SALT

    Caramelized brown sugar and French grey sea salt

    INGREDIENTS

    Cream, Skim milk, Organic fair-trade sugar, Brown cane sugar, Sweetened condensed milk (Milk, Sugar), Organic tapioca syrup, Organic butter (Organic cream, Lactic acid), Sea salt, Natural vanilla flavor, Organic carob bean, Baking soda.

  • COOKIES & CREAM

    COOKIES & CREAM

    Vanilla Bean ice cream, Oreo cookies

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Oreo Cookies (Unbleached enriched wheat flour, Sugar, Palm &/or canola oil, Alkalized cocoa, High fructose corn syrup, Leavening (Baking soda &/ or calcium phosphate), Cornstarch, Salt, Soy lecithin, Vanillin, Chocolate), Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic free-range egg yolks, Natural vanilla flavor and beans, Organic carob bean.

  • KEY LIME PIE

    KEY LIME PIE

    Key lime ice cream, crust pieces made from Stutzman Farm's freshly milled whole wheat

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Key lime juice, Organic butter (Organic cream, Lactic acid), Stutzman Farms’ organic whole wheat flour, Organic egg yolks, Organic carob bean.

  • BING CHERRY CHOCOLATE CHUNK

    BING CHERRY CHOCOLATE CHUNK

    Dark sweet cherry ice cream, Oregon Bing cherries, Fair-trade dark chocolate chunks

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Bing cherries and juice, Organic fair-trade sugar, Fair-trade dark chocolate (Sugar, Alkalized chocolate liquor, Cocoa butter, Milkfat, Soy lecithin, Natural flavors), Organic soy oil, Cane sugar, Natural flavor, Organic carob bean.

  • COOKIE DOUGH

    COOKIE DOUGH

    Vanilla Bean ice cream, homemade chocolate chip cookie dough

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Stutzman Farms’ organic wheat flour, Fair-trade chocolate chips (Sugar, Chocolate liquor, Cocoa butter, Soy lecithin, Vanilla), Organic butter (Organic cream, lactic acid), Pasteurized organic eggs, Natural vanilla flavor and beans, Organic tapioca starch, Sea salt, Organic carob bean.

  • FRESH STRAWBERRY

    FRESH STRAWBERRY

    Made with fresh strawberries, locally grown when in season

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Strawberries, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic egg yolks, Organic carob bean.

  • ROCKY ROAD

    ROCKY ROAD

    Fair-trade dark chocolate ice cream, locally-roasted almonds, marshmallow ribbon, fair-trade dark chocolate chunks

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Fair-trade dark chocolate (Sugar, Alkalized chocolate liquor, Cocoa butter, Milkfat, Soy lecithin, Natural flavors), Hillson’s roasted almonds [Almonds, Peanut oil, Butter (Cream, Salt)], Organic fair-trade alkalized cocoa, Organic eggs, Organic tapioca syrup and/ or corn syrup, Organic soy oil, Kosher gelatin (parve), Salt.

  • FRESH MINT CHOCOLATE CHUNK

    FRESH MINT CHOCOLATE CHUNK

    Mullberry Creek's organic fresh peppermint, Fair-trade dark chocolate chunks

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Fair-trade dark chocolate (Sugar, Alkalized chocolate liquor, Cocoa butter, Milkfat, Soy lecithin, Natural flavors), Organic egg yolks, Organic soy oil, Organic fresh peppermint, Peppermint extract, Organic carob bean.

  • CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER CUP

    CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER CUP

    Chocolate-peanut butter ice cream, peanut butter cups

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim Milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Peanut butter cups (Sugar, Coconut oil, Peanuts, Skim milk, Milk, Alkalized cocoa, Salt, Soy lecithin, Natural flavors), Roasted peanuts, Organic fair-trade alkalized cocoa, Salt, Organic carob bean.

  • BLUE COSMO™

    BLUE COSMO™

    Blue cotton candy ice cream, homemade marshmallow ribbon

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic free-range eggs, Corn and/or tapioca syrup, Natural & artificial flavor, Kosher gelatin (parve), Sea salt, Blue 1, Organic carob bean, Cream of tartar.

  • BLACK RASPBERRY CHOCOLATE CHUNK

    BLACK RASPBERRY CHOCOLATE CHUNK

    Oregon black raspberry ice cream, fair-trade dark chocolate chunks

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Black raspberries, Fair-trade dark chocolate (Sugar, Alkalized chocolate liquor, Cocoa butter, Milkfat, Soy lecithin, Natural flavors), Organic soy oil, Citric acid, Organic carob bean.

  • PEANUT BUTTER CHOCOLATE CHUNK

    PEANUT BUTTER CHOCOLATE CHUNK

    Peanut butter ice cream, Organic fair-trade milk chocolate chunks

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Roasted peanuts, Organic fair-trade milk chocolate (Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic fair-trade cacao beans, Organic milk, Organic fair-trade cocoa butter, Soy lecithin), Organic soy oil, Salt, Peanut oil, Organic carob bean.

  • PRALINES & CREAM

    PRALINES & CREAM

    Vanilla Bean ice cream, roasted caramel-encrusted pecans, caramel ribbon

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Pralined pecans [Sugar, Pecans, Butter (Cream, Salt), Natural flavor, Corn syrup, Salt], Organic egg yolks, Sweetened condensed milk (Milk, Sugar), Organic tapioca syrup, Organic butter (Organic cream, Lactic acid), Natural vanilla flavor and beans, Sea salt, Organic carob bean, Baking soda. 

     

  • TOASTED PISTACHIO

    TOASTED PISTACHIO

    Made with homemade pistachio butter

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Toasted pistachios, Organic egg yolks, Pistachio extract, Salt, Organic carob bean.

  • VANILLA BEAN YOGURT

    VANILLA BEAN YOGURT

    Made with Madagascar Bourbon vanilla beans

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Corn syrup, Organic fair-trade sugar, Cream, Organic egg yolks, Vanilla extract & beans, Organic carob bean, Live yogurt cultures.

  • MANGO SORBET

    MANGO SORBET

    Made from intensely flavorful Indian Alphonso mangoes

    INGREDIENTS

    Alphonso mangoes, Filtered water, Organic fair-trade sugar.

  • RASPBERRY SORBET

    RASPBERRY SORBET

    Made from select Oregon red raspberries

    INGREDIENTS

    Red raspberries, Filtered water, Organic fair-trade sugar.

  • VEGAN SALTED CARAMEL PECAN

    VEGAN SALTED CARAMEL PECAN

    Coconut milk flavored with homemade toasted pecan butter and caramelized brown sugar

    INGREDIENTS

    Coconut milk (contains xanthan & guar gum, carrageenan), Organic fair-trade sugar, Filtered water, Ground toasted pecans, Brown cane sugar, Sea salt, Natural vanilla flavor.

  • VEGAN CHOCOLATE

    VEGAN CHOCOLATE

    Made with coconut milk and fair-trade 72% dark chocolate

    INGREDIENTS

    Coconut milk (contains xanthan & guar gum, carrageenan), Organic fair-trade sugar, Fair-trade Belgian dark chocolate (Cocoa liquor, Sugar, Cocoa butter, Soy lecithin, Vanilla), Filtered water, Organic soy lecithin.

  • PEANUT BUTTER CHOCOLATE PRETZEL YOGURT

    PEANUT BUTTER CHOCOLATE PRETZEL YOGURT

    Peanut butter yogurt, chocolate-covered salted pretzel pieces

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Pretzel pieces [Pretzels (Unbleached enriched wheat flour, Malt, Salt, Soy oil, Yeast), Chocolate coating (Sugar, Coconut oil, Nonfat milk, Whole milk, Alkalized cocoa, Soy lecithin, Natural flavors)], Corn syrup, Organic fair-trade sugar, Roasted peanuts, Cream, Salt, Organic carob bean, Live yogurt culture.

  • CINNAMON

    CINNAMON

    Vietnamese cinnamon warmed with vanilla

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic egg yolks, Vietnamese cinnamon, Natural flavor, Organic carob bean.

  • FRESH MINT CHOCOLATE CHUNK

    FRESH MINT CHOCOLATE CHUNK

    Mullberry Creek's organic fresh peppermint, Fair-trade dark chocolate chunks

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Fair-trade dark chocolate (Sugar, Alkalized chocolate liquor, Cocoa butter, Milkfat, Soy lecithin, Natural flavors), Organic egg yolks, Organic soy oil, Organic fresh peppermint, Peppermint extract, Organic carob bean.

  • PEPPERMINT STICK

    PEPPERMINT STICK

    Fresh peppermint ice cream, peppermint stick flakes

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Peppermint candy (Sugar, Corn syrup, Vegetable juice colorants, Peppermint oil, Soy lecithin, Palm kernel oil), Organic egg yolks, Organic fresh peppermint, Peppermint extract, Organic carob bean.

  • VEGAN CHOCOLATE MINT TRUFFLE

    VEGAN CHOCOLATE MINT TRUFFLE

    Fair-trade 72% dark chocolate, cool peppermint, fair-trade dark chocolate chunks

    INGREDIENTS

    Coconut milk (contains xanthan & guar gum, Carrageenan), Belgian dark chocolate (Cocoa liquor, Sugar, Cocoa butter, Soy lecithin, Vanilla), Filtered water, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic soy oil, Peppermint extract, Organic soy lecithin.

  • EGG NOG

    EGG NOG

    Rich custard flavored with holiday spices & rum

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic egg yolks, Rum, Spices, Organic carob bean.

  • CHRISTMAS ALE GINGERSNAP

    CHRISTMAS ALE GINGERSNAP

    Great Lakes Christmas Ale ice cream & gingersnaps. A zero waste partnership between Great Lakes and Mitchell's

    INGREDIENTS

    Made from residual beer from the end of bottling runs—a zero waste partnership between Great Lakes & Mitchell’s.

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Great Lakes Christmas Ale, Stutzman Farms’ organic wheat flour, Organic butter (Organic cream, Lactic acid), Organic egg yolks, Spices, Ohio honey, Sea salt, Organic carob bean, Baking soda.

  • AMARETTO COOKIE

    AMARETTO COOKIE

    Amaretto and honey ice cream with amaretto cookie pieces and flecks of crushed pistachios.

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Stutzman Farms' organic wheat flour, Organic butter (Organic cream, Salt), Ohio honey, Toasted pistachios, Natural flavor, Baking soda, Salt.

  • TURTLE BROWNIE

    TURTLE BROWNIE

    Milk chocolate-caramel ice cream, salted pecans, fudge brownie pieces

    INGREDIENTS

    Cream, Skim milk, Organic fair-trade sugar, Hillson’s roasted pecans [Pecans, Peanut oil, Butter (Cream, Salt)], Organic fair-trade alkalized cocoa, Greenfield Farms’ organic eggs, Organic butter (Organic cream, Lactic acid), Stutzman Farms’ organic wheat flour, Organic sweetened condensed milk (Organic milk, Organic sugar), Organic tapioca syrup, Brown cane sugar, Natural vanilla flavor, Salt, Organic carob bean, Baking soda.   

  • AUTUMN CARAMEL APPLE

    AUTUMN CARAMEL APPLE

    Woolf Farm's cider flavored ice cream, crushed almonds, caramel ribbon

    INGREDIENTS

    Cream, Skim milk, Apple cider, Organic fair-trade sugar, Hillson’s roasted almonds [Almonds, Peanut oil, Butter (Cream, Salt)], Organic sweetened condensed milk (Organic milk, Organic sugar), Organic tapioca syrup, Organic butter (Organic cream, Lactic acid), Spices, Salt, Natural vanilla flavor, Organic carob bean, Baking soda.

  • PUMPKIN SPICE

    PUMPKIN SPICE

    Roasted pumpkin ice cream with autumn spices 

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Roasted pumpkin, Organic fair-trade sugar, Brown cane sugar, Spices, Organic carob bean.

  • WILDBERRY CRUMBLE

    WILDBERRY CRUMBLE

    Vanilla Bean ice cream, homemade wildberry ribbon, homemade crumble

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic blueberries, Black raspberries, Red raspberries, Stutzman Farms’ organic wheat flour and organic oats, Organic butter (Organic cream, Lactic acid), Organic egg yolks, Natural vanilla flavor and beans, Vietnamese cinnamon, Pectin, Citric acid, Organic carob bean.

  • LEMON BLACK RASPBERRY YOGURT

    LEMON BLACK RASPBERRY YOGURT

    Tart lemon yogurt, homemade black raspberry ribbon

    INGREDIENTS

    Skim milk, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic lemon juice, Corn syrup, Black raspberries, Cream, Sweetened condensed milk (Milk, Sugar), Pure lemon extract, Organic carob bean, Pectin, Citric acid, Live yogurt cultures.

  • PORTER CHOCOLATE CHUNK (Ohio City Exclusive)

    PORTER CHOCOLATE CHUNK (Ohio City Exclusive)

    Made with Edmund Fitzgerald Porter, and dark chocolate. Part of a zero-waste partnership with Great Lakes Brewing Company.

    INGREDIENTS

    Made from residual beer from the end of bottling runs—a zero waste partnership between Great Lakes & Mitchell’s.

    Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Fair-trade dark chocolate (Sugar, Alkalized chocolate liquor, Cocoa butter, Milkfat, Soy lecithin, Natural flavors), Great Lakes Edmund Fitzgerald Porter beer, Organic free-range egg yolks, Organic soy oil, Coffee, Organic carob bean.

  • COFFEE & COOKIES YOGURT

    COFFEE & COOKIES YOGURT

    Sumatran coffee yogurt with Oreo cookies.

    INGREDIENTS

    Ingredients: Skim milk, Corn syrup, Organic fair-trade sugar, Oreo Cookies [Unbleached enriched wheat flour, Sugar, Palm &/or canola oil, Alkalized cocoa, High fructose corn syrup, Leavening (Baking soda &/ or calcium phosphate), Cornstarch, Salt, Soy lecithin, Vanillin, Chocolate], Coffee, Organic egg yolks, Sweetened condensed milk (Milk, Sugar), Organic carob bean, Live yogurt cultures.